Form I-9 Authorized Representative Guide for Employers

Avatar Of John MclaneJohn McLane ·Apr 13, 2023 ·8 min read
Blank Papers And A Navy Folder On A Blue Desk

When a new employee starts far from your office, someone still needs to examine the documents used to complete Form I-9. A U.S. employer can designate a person to do that work on its behalf. Depending on state law, that person may be a notary public. For the federal form, the person signs as the employer’s authorized representative. The form itself does not call for notarization or a notary seal.

The distinction matters when an employee walks into a shipping store or calls a local notary. A request to “get this form notarized” can lead to the wrong service or a refused appointment. Tell the provider what you need instead: an authorized representative who can follow your instructions, examine the documents the employee chooses to present, and complete Section 2 on your behalf.

What a Form I-9 authorized representative does

Employers use Form I-9 to verify the identity and employment authorization of people they hire for employment in the United States. The employee completes and signs Section 1. The employer or its designated representative completes and signs Section 2 after examining the evidence the employee presents. Some employers assign this task to HR at a main office. Others appoint someone near the employee or at the job site.

The representative reviews the evidence and decides whether it reasonably appears genuine and relates to the employee. A representative records the required document information, enters the first day of employment and signs and dates the certification. That signature records who conducted the examination. A company employee who never examined the documents should avoid signing the certification in the representative’s place.

Give the person enough information to carry out the assignment. An appointment address and a blank form leave several decisions unresolved. Send a clear designation, the correct form and instructions, the employee’s start date, a secure return method, and a contact who can answer questions while the employee is there. The employer remains responsible for the representative’s work, including errors and omissions. Build in time for a second person to check the completed form.

Can a notary public complete Section 2?

A notary can perform this role where state law permits it. The person acts on the company’s behalf and signs in the space for the employer or authorized representative. Their notary commission does not change the federal signature requirements. Some states restrict what a notary can do when assisting with federal immigration forms. Check the rules where the representative will perform the service before making the appointment. A provider who turns down the request may be following those rules or the provider’s own service policy.

Ask, “Can you act as our authorized representative and complete Section 2 of Form I-9 after examining the employee’s documents in person?” Confirm that the provider will accept the employer’s designation and use the secure return process. If a provider handles only notarizations, arrange another qualified representative. A nearby company manager or an onboarding provider can be an option if they can follow the instructions and meet the deadline.

Consider whether the appointee will have time and privacy. A counter appointment in a crowded store can make it hard for the employee to discuss a name discrepancy or correct a date. A nearby office manager with a spare room and a direct line to HR may be able to complete the same task more smoothly. For recurring hires, identify a primary representative and a backup before you need either one.

Let the employee choose what to present

Give the employee the Lists of Acceptable Documents and explain the two paths. The employee generally presents one List A document or acceptable List A combination, which establishes both identity and employment authorization, or one List B document for identity together with one List C document for employment authorization. Instruct the representative to record the evidence the employee elects to present. A script that tells every hire to bring a passport, a driver’s license and a Social Security card can lead to unnecessary document requests.

During ordinary in-person examination, the employee generally presents original documents. The rules have specific exceptions, including certain certified copies and eligible receipts. A document shown in a phone photo, or emailed ahead as a scan, generally does not satisfy the ordinary physical examination requirement. Use the USCIS Form I-9 instructions to check the evidence rules before treating anything unusual as a missing document.

Set a clear escalation path. For example, an employee may present a receipt for replacing a lost document. The representative can ask HR to confirm whether the receipt is acceptable and when follow-up evidence is due. Another employee might present a document with a different last name. Ask HR how to resolve the discrepancy under the instructions and conduct the review privately. A standing instruction to demand another identity document whenever a name looks unfamiliar can result in inconsistent treatment.

Schedule the review around the first day of work

The employee must complete Section 1 no later than the first day of work for pay. They may complete it earlier, after accepting the job offer. The employer generally must complete Section 2 within three business days of that first day. If the job will last fewer than three business days, complete Section 2 no later than the first day of work for pay. Check holidays and the employee’s start date when setting up the appointment.

Suppose someone begins work for pay on Monday and Tuesday through Thursday are business days. Schedule the review early enough to complete Section 2 by Thursday. A Tuesday appointment gives HR time to handle a document question or reschedule if the representative is absent. For a two-day assignment starting Monday, arrange the review for Monday or complete it earlier after the offer has been accepted and the employee has completed Section 1.

Have the representative enter the actual date they sign. If an appointment is missed, coordinate promptly with HR to complete the review and document what happened according to your procedures. A start date, an appointment date and a signature date can all differ. Keep them straight so the completed record reflects what actually happened.

How the document review works in practice

Start by confirming that the employee has filled out and signed Section 1. Let the employee correct their own section if HR spots an omission. Check the start date against the information the employer supplied. Then examine the documents the employee presents and complete the appropriate Section 2 fields, including document title, issuing authority, number and expiration date where applicable. Write the employer’s information in the employer fields and use the representative’s information in the signature portion as instructed.

An Employee And A Representative Review Paperwork Across A Desk
A Designated Representative Can Examine The Employee’s Documents In Person.

Before the employee leaves, match each recorded field to the document and check that the right list or combination is recorded. Read back easily confused characters. Confirm that the signature and date are present. Return the form to HR through the designated secure channel. If a copy of a document must be retained, confirm who captures it and where it goes. The representative should know whether the employer needs copies before the appointment, so the employee is spared a second trip.

A workable process takes two people at different points. The representative performs and certifies the examination. HR checks the completed form for omissions and follows up under the applicable correction procedure. If HR receives an unsigned form, ask the representative to address the issue. When a correction is needed, preserve a record of what changed, who made the change and when. That makes a later review easier to understand.

When a video call can be used for remote examination

Employers who qualify under the DHS alternative procedure can remotely examine Form I-9 documents. The procedure is available to qualifying E-Verify participants in good standing and comes with specific conditions for participating hiring sites. For details, see E-Verify’s remote examination procedures. If the employer cannot use this option, a local authorized representative can conduct the physical examination for a remote hire.

Under the alternative procedure, the employer examines copies of the selected documents and conducts a live video interaction in which the employee presents the same documents. The employer indicates use of the alternative procedure on the form and retains clear, legible copies of the documents presented, including both sides when applicable. Employers using this option should also follow the applicable E-Verify requirements. An emailed scan and a quick call alone leave several required steps incomplete.

Tell the employee in advance whether the appointment will be in person or under the authorized remote procedure. For an in-person appointment, provide the representative’s location and explain which evidence the employee may choose to bring. For a remote appointment, supply a secure way to send the required copies and explain how to join the live interaction. Follow USCIS guidance on consistent use of the procedure and on offering physical examination when necessary.

Keep the completed form accessible and secure

Keep each Form I-9 throughout employment. After employment ends, employers generally retain each form until three years after the date of hire or one year after employment ends, whichever is later. If someone was hired May 6, 2024, and left August 20, 2026, the two retention dates are May 6, 2027, and August 20, 2027. Use the later date for the completed form. Keep any required supporting copies with the form or associated with it so they can be retrieved when necessary.

Document-copying requirements depend on the procedure and circumstances. For example, the DHS alternative procedure requires copies, and some E-Verify cases have their own document-copy requirements. If your company also chooses to make optional copies, apply that practice consistently and follow the relevant rules for storage and access. Limit access to employees who need the records. Collect sensitive documents through an approved channel and keep them out of a general onboarding inbox. If you are reviewing your broader onboarding setup, see our guide to Sage HR and employee record management. Assess your I-9 storage process against the applicable federal requirements before relying on a general HR tool for these records.

A checklist for your next off-site hire

  • Confirm the start date and calculate the Section 2 deadline. Leave enough time to arrange a replacement appointment if needed.
  • Choose a representative who can legally perform the service and follow your instructions. Give them a direct HR contact.
  • Provide the employee with the Lists of Acceptable Documents and the appointment details. Let the employee choose which acceptable evidence to present.
  • Tell the representative how to examine, record and return the evidence and form. Include instructions on copies and the secure handoff.
  • Check the returned form promptly for missing entries, signature and date. Track any required follow-up, including applicable receipt deadlines.
  • Store the form and associated copies in a secure system that can retrieve them on request. Record the hire date and the separation date when available so you can calculate retention.

A representative gives an employer a practical way to handle verification near the employee. Define the work before booking the appointment, give the employee clear choices, and review the returned form while there is still time to correct an omission. The person you appoint performs the examination. Your company owns the process and the record.

Avatar Of John Mclane

Legal technology writer with a J.D. and 15+ years of experience in federal and state courts. Covers data privacy, compliance, cybersecurity regulation, and technology-related legal issues for businesses and IT teams.